Canon Law

Notes, Commentary, Papers and Discussion

User Tools

Site Tools


rcri.legacy

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision
Previous revision
rcri.legacy [2019/08/29 14:42] amycsjrcri.legacy [2024/04/10 12:15] (current) – [Diverse situation] amycsj
Line 1: Line 1:
 ====== Religious Institutes Coming to Completion and Their Legacy ====== ====== Religious Institutes Coming to Completion and Their Legacy ======
-===== RCRI, October 3, 2019, Dallas Texas =====+
 ==== by Amy Hereford, CSJ, JD, JCD ==== ==== by Amy Hereford, CSJ, JD, JCD ====
 +
 +[[https://bit.ly/2MIBUL6|Link to presentation]]
  
 ===== Scope of the Issue ===== ===== Scope of the Issue =====
Line 11: Line 13:
   * Under this model, remaining institutes could have 5-10 institutes merging or affiliating   * Under this model, remaining institutes could have 5-10 institutes merging or affiliating
   * Does this model allow for the flourishing of these remaining institutes? or the flourishing of religious life?   * Does this model allow for the flourishing of these remaining institutes? or the flourishing of religious life?
 +
 ===== Indicia ===== ===== Indicia =====
   * Motu Proprio //Ecclesiae sanctae ('66)// gave indicia of decline   * Motu Proprio //Ecclesiae sanctae ('66)// gave indicia of decline
Line 16: Line 19:
   * the //lack of candidates// over a period of several years,    * the //lack of candidates// over a period of several years, 
   * the //advanced age// of the majority of its members.   * the //advanced age// of the majority of its members.
 +  * {{ :viability.png?400|  }}
 +===== Other responses =====
 +  * Covenant relationship - larger more stable communities take on the responsibility of caring for smaller more fragile communities. 
 +  * Commissary or Canonical Trustee - An individual religious appointed by the competent authority to take on responsibility for a community unable to supply its leadership. 
 +
 +
 +
 ===== Particular Challenges ===== ===== Particular Challenges =====
   * Providing //ongoing leadership// for the institute.   * Providing //ongoing leadership// for the institute.
-  * Providing //care for aging members,// in addition to health-care, this includes pastoral care and support of the members, those facing the challenges of aging and those moving out of full-time ministry, as well as those still in active ministry.+  * Providing //care for aging members,// in addition to health care, this includes pastoral care and support of the members, those facing the challenges of aging and those moving out of full-time ministry, as well as those still in active ministry.
   * Providing leadership in the //sponsored ministries.//   * Providing leadership in the //sponsored ministries.//
 +===== Diverse situation =====
 +  * Size
 +  * Location
 +  * Internal resources
 +  * Finances
 +  * Local/regional
 +    * support and capacity
 +    * Church
 +    * religious communities
 +  * Governance structure
 +  * Federation
 +
 ===== Cost of Eldercare ===== ===== Cost of Eldercare =====
   * 1986 NRRO formed by USCCB, CMSM, and LCWR to help address the funding shortfall   * 1986 NRRO formed by USCCB, CMSM, and LCWR to help address the funding shortfall
Line 52: Line 74:
   * Settling its legacy, and disposition of any remaining temporal goods.    * Settling its legacy, and disposition of any remaining temporal goods. 
 ===== Sponsorship ===== ===== Sponsorship =====
 +  * Having had the honor of participating in the mission of Jesus
   * Traditional Sponsorship   * Traditional Sponsorship
     * Ensuring the Mission and Catholic Identity     * Ensuring the Mission and Catholic Identity
Line 65: Line 88:
   * Funding   * Funding
     * Held in Operations, Fund or Trust     * Held in Operations, Fund or Trust
-      * Trust $$ held by Trustee for Beneficiary 
-        * Trustee - sisters or brothers, often leadership, now 
     * Trust $$ held by Trustee for Beneficiary     * Trust $$ held by Trustee for Beneficiary
       * Trustee        * Trustee 
-        * sisters or brothers, often leadership, +        * Sisters or brothers, often leadership, 
       * Beneficiary        * Beneficiary 
-        * sisters or brothers+        * Sick, aged and infirm sisters or brothers
     * To Trust or Not to Trust     * To Trust or Not to Trust
       * 80s-90s: shield assets from liability or diversion       * 80s-90s: shield assets from liability or diversion
Line 92: Line 113:
     * These persons will continue to support when canonical leadership transitions     * These persons will continue to support when canonical leadership transitions
 ==== Community Assistance Ministry ==== ==== Community Assistance Ministry ====
-{{ seal.png }}+{{ seal.png?350 }}
   * Collaborative Community Assistance Ministries   * Collaborative Community Assistance Ministries
   * Regional collaboration for support with Eldercare and Administration   * Regional collaboration for support with Eldercare and Administration
Line 146: Line 167:
     * Legacy clause in a retirement trust     * Legacy clause in a retirement trust
     * Legacy trust     * Legacy trust
 +===== Planning =====
 +  - What assets does the group have, financial, real estate, trusts, etc? And approximate value.
 +  - What is the current purpose or use of those assets?
 +  - What would be the legacy use of those assets? And what might the timeline look like?
 +  - What is the best way to ensure that the assets are used for the current purpose, then dedicated to the legacy purpose?
 +  * Since there is quite a variation in those answers, the way of moving forward could be quite different. 
 +
 +
 +|                ^ Asset         ^ Value      ^ Use/Purpose  ^ Legacy     ^
 +^ Sisters Inc    | Land          | $$$        | Sisters      |            |
 +^ Sisters Inc    | Land          | $$$        | Ministry      |            |
 +^ Sisters Inc    | Investments | $$$                       |
 +^ Trust    |           | $$$        | Sisters       |
 +^ Retirement Facility    |           | $$$        | Sisters       |
 +^ Ministry    |           | $$$        | Ministry       |
 +
 +
 ===== Take Aways ===== ===== Take Aways =====
   * Plan ahead   * Plan ahead
Line 153: Line 191:
   * Be generous and trust    * Be generous and trust 
  
 +===== Bibliography =====
 +Hereford, Amy. [[https://www.amazon.com/dp/1626983321/ref=cm_sw_em_r_mt_dp_U_sDMKDbSKATCGJ |Beyond the Crossroads: Religious Life in the 21st Century.]] New York: Orbis Books, 2019.
 +
 +———. “Canon 580: Aggregation and Covenants.” //Roman Replies and CLSA Advisory Opinions,// 2012, 83–86.
 +
 +———. “Canon 584: Merging of Institutes.” //Roman Replies and CLSA Advisory Opinions,// 2011, 90–93.
 +
 +———. “Canon 625: Minimum Numbers for Governance in a Religious Institute.” //Roman Replies and CLSA Advisory Opinions,// 2016.
 +
 +———. “Canon 634: Legacy Distributions for Religious Institutes.” //Roman Replies and CLSA Advisory Opinions,// 2018.
 +
 +———. “Charitable Trusts Twenty Five Years Later.” //Legal Bulletin// 73 (2002): 17–37.
 +
 +———. [[http://www.ahereford.org/subscription/post/newsletter74|“Congregational Legacy Trust.”]] //RLC Newsletter// 17, no. 4 (2017): 1–4.
 +
 +———. [[http://www.ahereford.org/subscription/post/newsletter73|“Ministerial Public Juridic Person.”]] //RLC Newsletter// 17, no. 3 (2017): 1–4.
 +
 +———. [[https://www.amazon.com/dp/1517028469/ref=cm_sw_em_r_mt_dp_U_.BMKDb1NW031V |Navigating Change]]: The Role of Law in the Life-Cycle of a Religious Institute. St. Louis, MO: Religious Life Project, 2015.
 +
 +———. “Practical Guidelines for Aging Religious Institutes.” In //RCRI Bulletin//, 4–20. Silver Spring, MD: RCRI, 2015.
 +
 +———. "Religious Institutes Coming to Completion and Their Legacy." Presentation at RCRI, October 3, 2019, Dallas Texas
 +
 +———. [[http://www.ahereford.org/subscription/post/newsletter72 |“Transitioning Leadership.”]] //RLC Newsletter// 17, no. 2 (2017): 1–4.
 +
 +———. “Transitioning Sponsorship.” //RCRI Bulletin// 17 (2017): 5–18.
  
 +[[http://www.ahereford.org/subscription|Sign up for RLC Newsletter (Religious Law and Consultation).]]
/users/ahereford.org/htdocs/canonlaw/data/attic/rcri.legacy.1567114971.txt.gz · Last modified: 2023/06/30 15:17 (external edit)